6 Top 12-inch Pizza Toaster Ovens All Pizza Fans Should Have

Are you a pizza connoisseur and lover looking to prepare 12-inch pizzas in a toaster oven?

If yes, this article is a must-read for you!

We have reviewed 6 different models in the first part of the article, including convection, combo, countertop, big, and stainless steel toaster ovens that can fit a 12-inch pizza inside. You can read them to see which one works best for your requirements. In the second part of the article, you can also read about features to keep in mind when purchasing such a kitchen appliance to get the model suited to your needs.

The Rundown

Best of Best 12-inch Pizza Toaster Oven
Black And Decker Toaster Oven RundownBlack And Decker Toaster Oven 12Inch Pizza
The deep curved oven interior can fit a 12-inch pizza inside, offering settings for pizza, toast, baking, broiling, potatoes, and more.
Jump To Review

Best Convection 12-inch Pizza Toaster Oven
Toshiba Convection Toaster Oven RundownToshiba Digital Toaster Oven
With a built-in convection fan that circulates hot air, you can use 9 settings to prepare pizza, toast, cookies, rotisserie, etc.
Jump To Review

Best Combo 12-inch Pizza Toaster Oven
Oster Digital Toaster Oven RundownOster Toaster Oven For 12-Inch Pizza
With 7 available settings including pizza and convection bake, you can toast up to 6 slices of bread and bake a 12-inch pizza.
Jump To Review

Best Countertop 12-inch Pizza Toaster Oven
Hamilton Beach 31127D Toaster Oven RundownHamilton Beach Toaster Oven 31127D
Featuring a roll-top door and settings for baking, broiling, and toasting, you can prepare 6 toast slices or a 12-inch pizza easily.
Jump To Review

Best Big 12-inch Pizza Toaster Oven
Nostalgia Toaster Oven 0.7 Cubic Feet RundownNostalgia Toaster Oven 0.7 Cubic Feet
The big model can toast 12 bread slices at once or bake two 12-inch pizzas at the same time with toast and convection settings.
Jump To Review

Best Stainless Steel 12-inch Pizza Toaster Oven
Breville Toaster Oven Self Clean RundownBreville The Compact Toaster Oven
With 4 quartz heating elements and 8 smart functions, you can toast 4 bread slices, bake a 12-inch pizza, broil, roast, and more.
Jump To Review

6 Top 12-Inch Pizza Toaster Ovens

Best of Best 12-inch Pizza Toaster Oven

Black And Decker Toaster Oven 12 Inch Pizza

Deep Curved Interior
This Black and Decker countertop convection oven 12-inch pizza capacity model has a deep curved interior so that you can even bake pizza in it, as well as toast bread. It uses convection technology to circulate heated air throughout the oven, making food cook faster and more evenly.

Black And Decker Toaster Oven

Glass Door Window
The interior of the oven can also hold casseroles and whole chickens inside. During cooking, you can monitor the process by taking a glance through the glass window on the door. Next to the oven door, the unit features a control panel with pushbuttons and a screen display.

Pizza & Other Settings
Besides settings for toast, bagels, baking, and broiling, the 12-inch pizza toaster oven also offers many other one-touch cooking presets. These include cookies, pizza, frozen snacks, potatoes, and convection. Besides fitting in a 12-inch pizza, you can also put 6 slices of bread in at once for toasting.

Black And Decker Toaster Oven Review

Cooks 20% Faster
The 6-slice convection toaster oven comes with a baking pan and a broiling rack included. It is engineered to cook 20% faster so that you can enjoy your pizza sooner. When cooking, you can also adjust the temperature and timer by using the up and down arrow buttons with the screen display.

Short Description:

  • convection air circulation for even cooking
  • the deep curved interior fits a 12-inch pizza
  • a control panel with pushbuttons and a screen
  • settings for pizza, cookies, bagels, potatoes, frozen snacks
  • bake, broil, toast, convection settings

Best Convection 12-inch Pizza Toaster Oven

Toshiba Digital Toaster Oven

6-Slice Capacity
This digital convection toaster oven can hold 6 toast slices inside the oven cavity simultaneously or fit a 12-inch pizza. Its body is constructed from stainless steel and has a large glass door. The control panel consists of a digital screen with three turning knobs so that you can easily choose the cooking functions and set up the timer and oven temperature.

Toshiba Convection Toaster Oven

Built-In Convection Fan
You can choose between 9 cooking functions to prepare many different meals inside the oven, not just toast and pizza. You can also bake, broil, reheat, make cookies, convection bake, rotisserie, and keep food warm. The 1500-Watt unit uses a convection fan to circulate hot air powerfully throughout the oven for faster and more uniform baking results.

Wide Temperature Range
The 12-inch pizza toaster oven can satisfy most of the everyday cooking needs, especially as you can adjust the oven temperature between 150 and 450 degrees Fahrenheit. The inside of the oven is coated in a non-sticking layer for easier cleaning. The oven rack has to different positions in the oven for flexible cooking, as well.

Toshiba Convection Toaster Oven Review

Precise Setting Adjustments
A crumb tray comes included in the package, along with the rotisserie set, baking pan, and a baking rack. Thanks to the digital screen, you can precisely adjust the temperature and the timer for specific cooking results. When using the rotisserie set, you can roast up to a 4-pound chicken.

Short Description:

  • the 6-slice oven holds a 12-inch pizza
  • stainless steel body, digital screen
  • offers 9 cooking programs to choose from
  • toast, bake, rotisserie, pizza, cookies, etc
  • a convection fan circulates hot air
  • temperature between 150 and 450°F

Best Combo 12-inch Pizza Toaster Oven

Oster Toaster Oven For 12-Inch Pizza

Fits Many Baking Pans
This 12-inch pizza toaster oven comes in black color with silver details and can even fit 6 toast slices in at once. Other than that, it can even fit baking pans measuring up to 2 inches in height, 10.5 inches in width, and 12.5 inches in length. When cooking, you can adjust the oven temperature between 150 and 450 degrees Fahrenheit.

OsterDigital Toaster Oven

Toasts, Bakes, Broils
It uses convection technology and offers a convection bake setting on the one-touch control panel. Besides that, you can choose between 6 other one-touch cooking presets, including pizza, toast, bake, broil, warm, and defrost. The interior light can be turned on with a touch of a button for checking in on the cooking process through the glass door.

Removable Parts
The crumb tray is removable from the unit for easy cleaning, allowing you to get rid of the food drips and bread crumbs that are collected at the bottom of the toaster oven broiler. The rack is also removable from the unit for easy cleanup. To get flaky crusts on foods, use the convection bake setting.

Oster Digital Toaster Oven Review

90-Minute Timer
Besides adjusting the temperature on the control panel, you can do the same with the oven timer, as well. When cooking, it allows you to set up the timer for up to 90 minutes. Once the timer is up, the oven will also shut off automatically to prevent burning and overheating.

Short Description:

  • fits a 12-inch pizza, 6 toast slices
  • for baking pans measuring 10.5 by 12.5 inches
  • control panel with one-touch cooking settings
  • convection bake, toast, broil, warm, defrost, etc
  • the removable crumb tray and oven rack
  • adjustable temperature between 150 and 450°F
  • 90-minute timer with automatic shut off

Best Countertop 12-inch Pizza Toaster Oven

Hamilton Beach Toaster Oven 31127D

Easy-Reach Design
If you want to save countertop space in front of the toaster oven, this model could help you do that. It is equipped with a glass oven door that opens upward and away from the countertop. At the same time, it prevents food spills from making a mess on the glass window and makes access to the food inside the oven easy.

Hamilton Beach 31127D Toaster Oven

For Flexible Cooking
The oven cavity offers two rack positions for flexible cooking and a baking pan also comes included for many cooking needs. The roll-top toaster oven can fit in a 12-inch pizza, 6 pieces of toast, or a baking pan measuring 9 by 11 inches. Besides toasting, it also offers settings for baking and broiling.

Adjustable Temperature
You can bake pizza, toast bread, but also roast vegetables and broil fish in this 12-inch pizza toaster oven. To achieve perfect results depending on the type of food you are cooking, you can adjust the temperature between 150 and 450 degrees Fahrenheit by turning the temperature control knob.

Hamilton Beach 31127D Toaster Oven Review

30-Minute Timer
To choose between baking, broiling, and toasting on the control panel, you will have to use the function control knob and turn it to the desired setting. To set up a cooking timer for up to 30 minutes, you can use the timer knob or even choose the stay-on setting on it.

Short Description:

  • the roll-top door opens upward
  • easy access to food, no spills on the door
  • settings for toast, bake and broil
  • fits 6 toast slices, a 12-inch pizza
  • suitable for 9 by 11-inch pans

Best Big 12-inch Pizza Toaster Oven

Nostalgia Toaster Oven 0.7 Cubic Feet

Holds Two 12-Inch Pizzas
This 12-inch pizza toaster oven has a 0.7 cubic feet capacity with two oven racks inside so that you can bake two 12-inch pizzas at the same time. It comes in red color and features an oval clear glass window on the door and is also equipped with retro-looking details. The inside of the oven can also hold 12 bread slices simultaneously.

Nostalgia Toaster Oven 0.7 Cubic Feet Review

4 Cooking Functions
On the right side of the oven door, the control panel consists of three turn-style control dials. The first one is used to set up the oven temperature from 200 to 450 Fahrenheit degrees. The function control knob can be used to choose between the four available cooking settings – bake, broil, toast, and convection bake.

Timer With Ding Sound
The large convection toaster oven also features a 60-minute timer and offers a stay-on function if you need to cook something for over one hour. When you set up the timer for up to one hour, the ding sound will alert you when cooking is done. With the timer, you can also set up a toasting program for lighter or darker toast shades.

Nostalgia Toaster Oven 0.7 Cubic Feet

Easy Maintenance
Once cooking is done, this unit will also be easy to clean up. The crumb tray collects food crumbs and drips at the bottom of the unit and is removable for quick cleaning. The oven racks and the baking pan can also be removed for cleanup.

Short Description:

  • 0.7 cubic feet capacity for 12 bread slices
  • two oven racks can hold two 12-inch pizzas
  • temperature adjustable between 200 and 450°F
  • 60-minute timer with a stay-on option
  • toast, bake, broil, and convection bake
  • removable racks, baking pan, and crumb tray

Best Stainless Steel 12-inch Pizza Toaster Oven

Breville The Compact Toaster Oven

4 Quartz Heating Elements
This 12-inch pizza toaster oven is ideal for countertop use and easily fits into any kind of decor thanks to the timeless stainless steel construction. It is equipped with four quartz heating elements and works with element IQ to deliver the right heat at the right time.

Breville Toaster Oven Self Clean

8 Cooking Functions
The oven cavity can be used for toasting 4 slices of bread at once or baking up to a 12-inch pizza. The control panel also offers settings for toasting and pizza. With 8 cooking settings in total, you can also choose to bake, broil, reheat, roast, and prepare bagels and cookies. The screen display calculates the temperature and time for food depending on the program you choose.

User-Friendly Design
The stainless steel toaster oven can even roast a chicken and fit a 6-cup muffin tray inside. The interior walls of the oven are non-stick coated for easy cleaning. The glass window on the toaster oven offers guidelines for rack positions according to the type of food you are cooking. It also allows you to take a glance inside the oven without opening the door.

Breville Toaster Oven Self Clean Review

The Control Panel
The control panel features a backlit screen display, a start/cancel button, and two control knobs. The knobs are used for choosing the cooking function and setting the temperature and timer. The digital screen illuminates orange during preheating and cooking, and turns blue once done.

Short Description:

  • stainless steel body, clear glass door
  • features a backlit screen and 2 knobs
  • fits 4 bread slices, a 12-inch pizza
  • it features 8 cooking functions
  • toast, bake, broil, pizza, reheat, roast, etc
  • non-stick coated interior oven walls
  • multiple oven rack positions available

What To Consider In 12-Inch Pizza Toaster Ovens?

To get the best toaster oven that fits 12-inch pizzas, here we talk about a couple things to keep in mind. Firstly, look out for the capacity of the appliance to make sure it can fit such a pizza inside. Secondly, make sure that the oven is easy to use and that it offers cooking programs you plan to use. Finally, look out for other adjustable features and learn about the benefits of having such a small kitchen appliance.

The Capacity – Toaster ovens that can fit a 12-inch pizza inside can usually also hold around 6 slices of toast. This makes them ideal for family use. However, when choosing a countertop toaster oven, it is also important to look for the overall dimensiosn to make sure it can fit your available worktop space.

Easy To Use – For a toaster oven to be easy to use, there are a couple things to look out for. Firstly, make sure that the control panel is intuitive to use so that you can find all the settings easily. Moreover, look for functions and controls that are clearly labeled for that purpose, as well. For models with screen displays, make sure they are easy to read.

Cooking Programs – Besides toasting bread, you should look for models that have a dedicated setting to preparing pizza. Moreover, you could get a model that can also bake, broil, rotisserie, air fry, defrost, dehydrate, reheat, keep warm, etc. Multifunction toaster ovens will be of great help in the kitchen without taking up too much space.

Adjustable Features – For flexible cooking, look for models that offer more than one position of the rack inside the oven cavity. Besides that, look for the convenience of models that offer a wide temperature range and a timer for precise cooking. Some models will also let you choose between light, medium, and dark toast shades.

Benefits – A 12-inch pizza toaster oven can be used as extra help in busy kitchens or as an alternative to conventional ovens in small and confined spaces. It can also preheat faster while using less energy and producing less heat in the kitchen than big ovens. It is also easier to maintain clean.

To Wrap It Up

The Black and Decker convection oven 12 inch pizza model is the one that stood out the most to us. This 12-inch pizza toaster oven has a dedicated pizza setting, and can also be used for frozen snacks, potatoes, baking, toasting bread, broiling, and more. It cooks fast and evenly thanks to convection that circulates hot air within the oven. For slightly bigger models of toaster ovens, check out our selection of 8-slice toaster ovens. To bake larger pizzas at once, consider the reviewed models of extra-large convection countertop ovens.

Meghan began her career as a journalist in 2016 after graduating with a Master’s degree. Through her work as a journalist, she has built relationships with many industry leaders, including experts in cooking which prompted her interest in cuisine. In 2018, she joined a cooking course where she explored many tips and tricks she presents in her articles and reviews. Meghan joined the Kitchentoast team in 2020 and since then, she has been focusing on writing about cooking, baking, design, kitchen appliances, and more.