Looking to invest in a safe toaster oven?
Unsure of which model to go for?
In that case, continue reading this article, where we have reviewed different models packed with safety features. The reviews of the best PTFE-free, toaster ovens suitable for the elderly, as well as 4-slice, countertop, and convection models await you below. Besides that, you can also check out our buying guide to help make your search for an appropriate appliance much easier.
The Rundown
Best Of Best Safe Toaster Oven
COMFEE Compact Toaster Oven
Made of stainless steel for safety and durability, this model can fit 4 bread slices and is used for toasting, broiling, and baking.
Jump To Review
Best PTFE-Free Safest Toaster Oven
Oster Large Toaster Oven
Free of PTFE coatings that can leach toxins into your food, this model offers a large capacity and 7 preset cooking programs.
Jump To Review
Best For Elderly Safe Toaster Oven
Cuisinart Toaster Oven Airfryer
Elderly people can enjoy their favorite fried foods cooked with air circulation for less fat and healthier meals, and more.
Jump To Review
Best Convection Safest Toaster Oven
Toshiba Digital Toaster Oven
Offering 10 cooking programs that are easy to set up, this oven offers a convection feature for faster and safer cooking.
Jump To Review
Best 4-Slice Safe Toaster Oven
Hamilton Beach Easy Reach Oven
By holding up to 4 slices of bread at once, this toaster oven is also safe to use with a roll-top door that moves out of the way.
Jump To Review
Best Countertop Safest Toaster Oven
VIVOHOME Toaster Oven
Featuring a non-stick stainless steel interior, this oven is equipped with four heating elements and is safe for countertops.
Jump To Review
Best 6 Safest Toaster Ovens
Best Of Best Safe Toaster Oven
COMFEE Compact Toaster Oven
Small Footprint
This safe toaster oven has a 4-slice capacity that, along with the compact size, leaves a small footprint on kitchen countertops. It features a glass door for checking in on the baking process inside the oven at any time. The outer body is made of stainless steel for safety and durability, while the silver color makes it easily fit into any decor.
Two Control Knobs
The control panel on this toaster oven has two control knobs for adjusting the oven temperature and setting up a timer for up to 30 minutes. The temperature can be adjusted between 150 and 450 degrees Fahrenheit for baking, broiling, and toasting cooking functions.
Straightforward Use
The built-in 30-minute timer offers settings for precise toast shade adjustments. Besides that, the stay-on function lets you use the oven for longer cooking needs. The two control knobs make operation very easy and straightforward and are enough to meet your daily cooking needs.
Dual Heating Elements
The inside of the oven can fit up to a 9-inch pizza. It is very easy to use and clean and comes with a non-stick crumb tray. This tray is used to make cleaning effortless while collecting all the crumbs and grease from inside the oven. The dual heating elements on the toaster oven broiler make broiling, toasting, and baking more precise.
Short Description:
- a 4-slice oven can hold a 9-inch pizza
- the stainless steel body is safe and durable
- features temperature and timer control knobs
- two heating elements for baking, broiling, etc
- a 30-minute timer and stay-on function
Best PTFE-Free Safest Toaster Oven
Oster Large Toaster Oven
Safe & Non-Toxic
If you are worried about cooking food with the presence of Teflon in your kitchen appliances, this model is the one for you. The PTFE-free toaster oven has a large 6-slice capacity that can hold a baking pan with measurements up to 10.5 inches in width, 12.5 inches in length, and 2 inches in height. At the same time, you don’t have to worry about any toxins leaching into the cooked food.
Wide Temperature Range
The oven features convection technology for faster cooking and with a wide temperature range between 150 and 450°F, it can offer much of the conventional oven options. The digital screen display with pushbuttons makes setups easy. You can use it for broiling, baking, defrosting, pizza, toast, and warming foods.
Large Capacity
The digital convection toaster oven also gives you an option to turn on the light inside the oven, allowing you to easily check in on the baking progress through the glass door. It is big enough to accommodate a 12-inch pizza, but also casseroles, roasts, and cookies.
User-Friendly Design
By circulating hot air, the oven creates crispy food and even browning on toast, while letting you choose between lighter and darker toast shades. The two rack positions promise adjustments according to the size of the food you are putting in the oven. With one-touch operations, it is very easy and safe to use.
Short Description:
- the PTFE-free oven holds 6 bread slices
- the convection setting circulates hot air
- a digital screen with 7 cooking functions
- temperatures between 150 and 450°F
- it accommodates casseroles and 12-inch pizzas
- bake, broil, defrost, toast, pizza, warm options
Best For Elderly Safe Toaster Oven
Cuisinart Toaster Oven Airfryer
Healthier Fried Foods
This safe toaster oven for elderly use has a convection setting for faster and more even cooking, while also offering you the possibility of air frying foods. By using hot air, the elderly can enjoy their favorite fried meals and snack with a healthy twist. By using air to fry, the amounts of grease and fats are reduced for healthier eating habits.
Easy To Set Up
The air fryer convection toaster oven lets you not just air fry, but also bake, toast, and broil. To operate the oven, it comes with four turning knobs that are easy to set up. The first knob lets you set up a timer for up to 1 hour. Once the time is up, the oven will automatically shut off to prevent overheating and ensure safety.
Adjustable Settings
The 0.6 cubic feet oven can heat up to 450°F, depending on the cooking application you want to use. The temperature is easy to set up with the knob. The third knob can be used for choosing between air fry, convection bake, bake, broil, convection broil, toast, and warm.
Selectable Shade
The fourth control knob is to be used for selecting between different toast shades by setting up a timer for toasting bread. An oven rack and an air frying basket are included with the oven, as well as a baking pan. The air frying function is great for preparing wings, fries, shrimps, fritters, etc.
Short Description:
- a convection feature for air frying
- healthy fried foods with hot air
- options for baking, broiling, toasting, etc
- features four control knobs for setup
- 0.6 cubic feet oven with a baking tray
- adjustable temperature, 1-hour timer
- suitable for elderly, fewer fats and grease
Best Convection Safest Toaster Oven
Toshiba Digital Toaster Oven
10 Preset Programs
This safe toaster oven has a convection feature and offers 10 cooking functions to choose from. The oven can fit 6 bread slices at once or even a 12-inch pizza, a 4-pound chicken, casseroles, and cookies. It offers temperatures between 150 and 400 Fahrenheit degrees for versatile cooking needs.
3 Control Knobs
The control panel features a digital display with three turning knobs. The function control knob allows you to choose between settings for toast, pizza, baking, broiling, defrosting, reheating, rotisserie, cookies, keep warm, and convection. The second knob is used for setting up the oven temperature.
Simple Setup
The third knob is used for setting up a cooking timer for up to 2 hours. The display is bright for easy use and the convenient turning knobs make setups very simple. You can choose between 3 rack positions according to the food and the size of the food you plan to cook inside the oven. The convection oven cooks faster while making it safe for your kitchen.
Roasted & Delicious Foods
A crumb tray is removable from the unit for easy cleaning, and the inner walls are non-sticking and can be washed with a damp cloth. The large convection toaster oven locks the flavor and juices of food, while the rotisserie option allows you to prepare roasted meats for uniform cooking while slowly rotating it.
Short Description:
- features 10 preset programs to choose from
- fits 6 slices, a 12-inch pizza, a 4-pound chicken
- temperature adjustable between 150 and 400°F
- a digital display and three control knobs
- a 2-hour timer, 3 rack positions available
Best 4-Slice Safe Toaster Oven
Hamilton Beach Easy Reach Oven
Easy & Safe Food Access
This roll-top toaster oven can hold up to 4 slices of bread at once. The roll-top door means that the door opens upward, allowing you to easily and safely access the foods inside the oven. That way, you can safely access the inside of the oven before during, and after cooking. The food also won’t be able to spill on the glass door and make a mess.
Contoured Knobs
This safest toaster oven has 2 rack positions and includes a baking pan for versatile cooking needs. The temperature knob allows you to choose the oven temperature between 200 and 450°F. The timer knob offers settings for different toast colors and can be set up for 30 minutes. The knobs are safe to use as they are contoured for a better grip.
Auto Shut Off
The oven cavity is big enough to fit a 9-inch pizza and the glass door is removable for easy cleaning. After setting up a timer, the oven will automatically shut off once cooking is finished. The crumb tray is accessible from the front for easy cleaning, as well.
Bakes & Broils
With this oven, you can not just toast bread, but also bake and broil foods. As the door opens upward, the countertop space will always stay unoccupied in front of this small kitchen appliance. The door will never be under the rack when putting or removing food, preventing any mess on the glass door.
Short Description:
- a 4-slice capacity fits a 9-inch pizza
- features a roll-top glass door
- safe and easy access to food without spills
- adjustable temperature between 200 and 450°F
- a 30-minute timer with auto shut off
- for toasting, broiling, and baking
Best Countertop Safest Toaster Oven
VIVOHOME Toaster Oven
Safe & Secure
This model is one of the safest toaster ovens for any kitchen countertop. It features feet that make it stand safely and securely on top of the counter. The inside of the oven features four heating elements at the bottom and top and can hold 6 bread slices at once. The 16-liter capacity is also suitable for holding a 9 by an 11.8-inch baking pan.
3 Cooking Functions
The countertop toaster oven heats quickly and achieves precise temperatures easily for uniform cooking. It can be used for toasting (uses top and bottom elements), broiling (top elements), and baking (uses only bottom elements). The temperature control knob allows you to set up the oven temperature between 150 and 450°F.
4-Position Rack
It is even possible to set up a cooking timer for up to 60 minutes and the bell will signal when the food is ready. The oven rack has four positions so that you can adjust it to the type and quantity of food you are cooking. You can enjoy roasted meats, up to a 10-inch pizza, muffins, fish, vegetables, and more.
Safety Accessories
The inner oven cavity is non-sticking and made of stainless steel for easy cleaning. Cooking in this oven is both safe and easy with a slide-out tray. The glass door allows you to monitor the cooking process, while a drag hook and a heat-resistant oven mitten make any handling of hot surfaces easy and safe.
Short Description:
- safe and secure to use on countertops
- fits 6 slices, a 10-inch pizza inside
- four heating elements for uniform cooking
- it can toast, bake, and broil different foods
- 60-minute timer and a ready bell signal
- slide-out tray, four-position oven rack
- stainless steel non-stick inner cavity
What To Consider In Safest Toaster Ovens?
To ensure the safety of you and your family, as well as your kitchen, a toaster oven should boast some of the following qualities. Firstly, it should be made of safe materials that are both food-grade and durable. Secondly, look for their capacity and consider models that are easy to use to make them as safe as possible. Finally, find out about the accessories they come with.
Material – PTFE, or Teflon, is a widely common and used material in kitchenware and cookware. It provides the unit with non-sticking properties but can also be harmful to your health when heated above certain temperatures. That is why you should avoid these materials that can leach toxins into your food. Instead, opt for materials such as stainless steel.
Capacity – Toaster ovens come in different capacities and most can hold 4 to 6 bread slices. Depending on their capacity, their size will also vary. However, most are compact enough to easily fit any kitchen countertop. The best model for you will be the one that fits your space while also offering you a big enough capacity for your needs.
Ease Of Use – Safest toaster ovens also need to be easy to use, without complicated functions and instructions. That is why you should look for clear labels on functions and controls. You can get a model with turning knobs or opt for intuitive-to-use digital models. Models with timers and automatic shutoff functions are very appreciated for safety.
Cooking Presets – A toaster oven can usually do much more than just toasting bread. It mostly also offers baking and broiling functions. Some models can also air fry, for deliciously fried foods with fewer fats and less grease. Multifunction toaster ovens will offer you the possibility of also baking pizza, preparing bagels, rotisserie, making cookies, etc.
Accessories – To make operation both safe and simple, most toaster ovens are equipped with a baking pan and an oven rack. A crumb tray is important as it collects all the crumbs and grease that accumulate inside the oven and should be easily removable for fast cleanup.
To Wrap It Up
As our top choice, we would like to present you with the Comfee safest toaster oven. It is safe and durable with a stainless steel body, a 30-minute timer, and a 4-slice capacity. It is equipped with dual heating elements and is easy to keep clean. If you wish to purchase a model that turns off when the timer expires, check out our reviews of toaster ovens with auto shut off. To stay safe and prevent burns, you might also be interested in our selection of cool-touch toaster ovens.
