Best 6 Old-Fashioned Style Waffle Makers In 2021 Reviews




Are you interested in purchasing an old fashioned waffle iron?

Then you are in the right place!

Listed below, you can find my reviews of the six best models that are currently available on the market. I compared their designs, beneficial features, and prices to ensure that you easily find the perfect one.

The Rundown

Best Of Best Old Fashioned Waffle Iron
Skeppshult Heart-Shape Waffle Maker Rundown Skeppshult Heart-Shape Waffle Maker
A heart-shaped waffle maker that provides powerful performance and is made out of PFOA, PTFE, and cadmium-free materials.
Jump To Review

Best Belgian Old Fashioned Waffle Maker
Wayerty Waffle Maker Rundown Wayerty Waffle Maker
A Belgian waffle maker that is very easy to use and features a slim design for more convenient storage.
Jump To Review

Best Cast Iron Old Fashioned Waffle Iron
Rome Industries Waffle Maker Rundown Rome Industries Waffle Maker
A cast iron waffle maker that features extremely durable construction and provides very quick performance.
Jump To Review

Best Cast Aluminum Old Fashioned Waffle Maker
NordicWare 15040 Rundown NordicWare 15040 Waffle Maker
A cast-aluminum waffle maker that features a four-slice square shape and has fully coated non-stick cooking plates.
Jump To Review

Best Round Old Fashioned Waffle Iron
Orvis Chuck Wagon Waffle Iron Rundown Orvis Chuck Wagon Waffle Iron
A round waffle maker that comes with two separate cooking plates that easily lock together during the cooking process.
Jump To Review

Best Stovetop Old Fashioned Waffle Maker
Lehman's Waffle Maker Rundown Lehman’s Waffle Maker
An affordable stovetop waffle maker that features a pre-seasoned cooking surface and requires very little maintenance.
Jump To Review

Best 6 Old-Fashioned Waffle Makers

Best Of Best Old Fashioned Waffle Iron

Skeppshult Heart-Shape Waffle Maker

Heart-Shaped Design
Even though this is an old fashioned waffle maker, it features a modern, heart-shaped design. It is made to cook one five-slice waffle at a time. You will get perfectly cooked waffles in a very short time.

Skeppshult Heart-Shape Waffle Maker

Versitile Use
The best thing about this waffle maker is that it is specially designed to ensure that you can use it on all kinds of stovetops including gas, electric, ceramic, radiant, or halogen. It is the perfect choice for everyone who is looking for a versatile waffle maker.

Powerful Performance
You can be sure that this waffle maker will provide you with a very powerful performance. It is made out of magnetic cast iron materials that distribute heat throughout the cooking plate much better than other cookware and also works perfectly with high temperatures.

Skeppshult Heart-Shape Waffle Maker rEVIEW

Food-Safe Materials
Another very important thing about this heart-shaped waffle maker is that it is entirely constructed out of food-safe materials that contain no PFOA-s, PTFE-s, or cadmium. This means that it contains no harmful chemicals that could damage the quality of your ingredients.

Short Description:

  • five-slice heart-shaped design
  • designed for use on versatile stovetops
  • highly durable non-stick coat
  • powerful heat distribution throughout the cooking surface
  • very quick and time-efficient performance
  • entirely PFOA, PTFE, and cadmium-free
  • very easy to clean and maintain

Best Belgian Old Fashioned Waffle Maker

Wayerty Waffle Maker

Belgium-Style Waffles
This old fashioned waffle maker is specially designed to make delicious Belgium-style waffles. It doesn’t provide precise temperature controls but you can simply control how far from the heat you hold it. You can make perfectly crips brown waffles or light fluffy ones.

Wayerty Waffle Maker

Simple Use
One of the great things about this double Belgian waffle maker is that it is very easy and simple to use. It is designed to ensure that you can use it on both stovetops and over a campfire. It will heat up very quickly and ensure time-efficient cooking performance.

Easy To Clean
Because of its non-stick cooking surface, this Belgian waffle maker will be very easy to clean. Once you are done using it, simply wait for the cooking plates to cool down completely, wash them with some mild water, and dry them up thoroughly with a clean paper towel.

Wayerty Waffle Maker Review

Slim Profile
Since this waffle maker features a slim profile, you won’t have any trouble finding the perfect storage space for it. You can even detach its handles to ensure that it easily fits inside your kitchen drawers.

Short Description:

  • creates two Belgium-style waffles at a time
  • very simple and easy to use
  • requires very little maintenance
  • features a highly-practical slim profile

Best Cast Iron Old Fashioned Waffle Iron

Rome Industries Waffle Maker

Durable Construction
This is another old fashioned waffle maker that features a durable cast iron construction. Thanks to this feature you can be sure that it is highly durable and that it will have a long life-span.

Rome Industries Waffle Maker

Short Handles
The only downside of this Rome old fashioned waffle iron is that it comes with very short cast iron handles that will transmit the heat from the unit. This means that you will need to use heat-resistant gloves. Otherwise, you might end up suffering a heat-burn.

Quick Performance
Because of its construction, this waffle maker will also provide you with amazing performance. Simply pour in the waffle batter, close the top lid, and place the cooking plates over the fire. Wait three minutes, flip the unit over, and bake the waffles for another minute.

Rome Industries Waffle Maker Review

Maintenance tips
Here are some maintenance tips to ensure that this antique cast iron waffle maker provides you with the most amazing performance. You should coat it with some cooking oil every once in a while to ensure that its non-stick layer keeps its properties.

Short Description:

  • features antique Rome design
  • durable cast iron construction
  • comes with very short handles
  • works on both fire and gas stoves

Best Cast Aluminum Old Fashioned Waffle Maker

NordicWare 15040 Waffle Maker

Square Shape
This old fashioned waffle maker comes in a common square shape. It will allow you to make up to four small waffles at the same time. You can use it to make a delicious breakfast in no time.

NordicWare 15040

Stovetop Use
Because of its design, this waffle maker is made for use over gas stovetops. This means that you can use it both at home and on your camping trips. It comes in a practical size that makes it very easy to transport and carry on your family vacations.

Non-Stick Coat
The amazing thing about this waffle maker is that it has a high-quality non-stick coat. Thanks to this feature you will be able to easily remove the waffles from the unit once they are cooked. It also means that it will require very little maintenance.

NordicWare 15040 Review

Simple Cleanup
This cast aluminum square Belgian waffle maker is very easy to clean. Note that you need to wash it manually since the cooking plates are not dishwasher-safe. Use lukewarm water and mild dish soap to remove all possible batter leftovers from the cooking plates and store it away for the next use.

Short Description:

  • four-slice square shape
  • designed for gas stovetop use
  • high-quality non-stick coat
  • requires very little maintenance
  • easy to transport and carry

Best Round Old Fashioned Waffle Iron

Orvis Chuck Wagon Waffle Iron

Round Shape
This old fashioned waffle maker comes in a round shape and can make one large four-slice waffle at a time. You can use it on your kitchen stovetops, over gas cookers, or even on open campfires. It will always provide great performance.

Locking Plates
Another great thing about this waffle maker is that it comes with two separate cooking plates that easily lock together for the cooking process. This feature also makes it much easier to clean and maintain.

Orvis Chuck Wagon Waffle Iron

Wooden Handles 
Unlike other models in this post, this waffle maker comes with very long wooden handles. This is an amazing feature because it means that you never have to worry about heat burns. Wood as a material doesn’t transmit the heat so your hands will be perfectly safe during the cooking process.

Hanging Strap
You won’t have any trouble finding the perfect storage space for this round waffle maker. It comes with a leather hanging strap that will allow you to hang the waffle maker inside your pantry or any other convenient storage space you have.

Short Description:

  • round four-slice design
  • two separate locking cooking plates
  • high-quality non-stick coat
  • features two heat-resistant wooden handles
  • works on stovetops, gas cookers, and campfires
  • a great choice for outdoor use

Best Stovetop Old Fashioned Waffle Maker

Lehman’s Waffle Maker

Stovetop Use
Just like all of the models, that are listed above in this post, this old fashioned waffle maker is also designed for stovetop use. It works best over gas stovetops, but you can also use it on electric ones. Note that it is not designed for use on induction or smooth glass cooking surfaces.

Lehman's Waffle Maker

Pre-Seasoned Cooking Surface
The important thing about this waffle maker is that it comes with pre-seasoned cooking surfaces. This means that it is ready to use straight out of the package. You can season it again every once in a while with a cooking oil you usually use.

Affordable Price
This stovetop waffle iron comes at an affordable price. It costs less than forty dollars which makes it a great choice for everyone who is looking for a budget-friendly unit that provides the same beneficial features as other models.

Lehman's Waffle Maker Review

Additional Tips
Since this waffle maker also comes with somewhat smaller and shorter handles you might want to keep heat-resistant gloves nearby while cooking waffles. That way you will be able to easily flip the unit when needed without worrying about heat burns.

Short Description:

  • designed for stovetop use
  • features a pre-seasoned cooking surface
  • comes at an affordable price of fewer than 40 dollars
  • doesn’t work on induction and glass cooking surfaces

What To Consider About The Old Fashioned Waffle Irons?

Old fashioned waffle irons come in many different designs and sizes. You can easily find both smaller and big waffle makers that offer pretty much the same features. Here are the most important things you want to check when buying a waffle maker.

Construction Material – The first thing you need to consider is the material out of which the waffle maker is made. Most of these models are made either out of cast-aluminum or cast-iron material and they provide high durability.

Stovetop Compatibility – Another thing you need to consider is stovetop compatibility. Most of the listed models are compatible with gas stovetops, portable gas cookers, campfires, etc. However, they are usually not compatible with glass stovetops or induction.

Coated Cooking Plates – Always make sure that the model you decide to buy comes with fully coated non-stick cooking plates. That way your waffles will simply slip out of the unit once they are cooked and you won’t have to spend a lot of your time on the cleaning process.

Cool-Touch Handles – Since all of these old-style waffle makers are made for use over direct flame and they are made out of materials that ensure fast and powerful heat transmission, it’s very important that you find a model that comes with cool-touch handles. Otherwise, you will need to have heat-resistant gloves nearby while you cook.

Price Range – The models that I reviewed in this post come in a wide price range. They cost from thirty dollars all the way to more than one hundred. In general, you can find both expensive and cheap models. It only depends on the features you are determined that you want your waffle maker to have.

To Wrap It Up

The best old fashioned waffle iron is the Skeppshult Heart-Shape Waffle Maker. It provides a modern heart-shaped design, can be sued on versatile cooktops, and is entirely made out of food-safe PFOA, PTFE, and cadmium-free materials. Read more about the best flat waffle makers and choose the best camping waffle iron on the market.




Patricia
Patricia has a Bachelor’s in Economics and experience in the restaurant. She finished her education in 2015. and joined a cooking team as a restaurant manager. Her work with chefs helped her to become a successful freelance writer. She writes about kitchen appliances by chefs’ recommendations but in accordance with the interests of ordinary people. Except for appliances, she writes about receipts she has collected through her work before she joined the Kithentoast team in 2020.